IV Crush: Why My Puts Lost Money When the Stock Fell 13%

IV crush can make an option lose value even when you are right on direction. A real FSLY trade: the stock fell 13% after earnings and my puts still lost.

Share
IV Crush, Explained With a Real Trade cover

IV crush is the sharp drop in an option's implied volatility right after an expected event, most often an earnings report. It can make an option lose value even when the stock moves the way you bet. In August it happened to me on Fastly (FSLY): the stock fell 13% after earnings, and my puts still lost money. This post shows why, with the real numbers, and what I do differently now.

New to options? Start with Options Trading for Beginners: The Complete Guide.

Key takeaways

  • Before earnings, options price in a big move. Implied volatility rises because nobody knows the result yet.
  • After the report, that uncertainty is gone. Implied volatility drops overnight, and so does the option's price.
  • Being right on direction is not enough. The stock has to move more than the options already priced in.
  • Out-of-the-money options suffer most. Their price is mostly volatility, not distance to the strike.
  • Real result: FSLY fell 13% after earnings and my puts lost 19% that day. The same view, bought after the report, made 82%.

What is IV crush?

Implied volatility (IV) is the size of move the options market expects, built into the option's price. Before earnings, nobody knows the result, so IV rises and options get more expensive. Once the report is out, the big unknown is gone. IV falls back to normal, often in one session. That fall is IV crush.

The crush hits every option on the stock, calls and puts. Vega tells you how much: it is the dollar change in the option's price for each 1 point change in IV. A put with a vega of $0.017 loses about $0.60 per share when IV drops 35 points, before the stock moves at all.

Implied vs realized volatility

Implied volatility is what the market expects. Realized volatility is how much the stock actually moves. A long option before earnings is a bet that realized will beat implied. If the stock moves less than priced in, the option loses even when the direction is right. If it moves more, the option can win despite the crush.

Real trade: FSLY, a put bet that was right and still lost

The thesis. I was bearish on Fastly with a price target of $12. Revenue growth was slowing, from 23% in the fourth quarter of 2025 to a 14% full year guide for 2026. Capital spending was rising from 5% to 10 to 12% of revenue, while free cash flow margin sat near 5%. The top 10 customers made up a growing share of revenue, and management had stopped reporting total customer count and retention.

The position.

  • July 10: bought 30 September $17.50 puts at $2.23. Cost: $6,704.
  • July 13: sold 15 August $15 puts at $0.90, one short put for every two long ones, to pay part of the waiting time.
  • August 4: bought the short puts back at $0.15, the day before the report. Profit: $1,111.

Into the report. The stock rallied from $20 to $26 in the weeks before earnings, so the puts were already down to $0.65. Their IV was 118%: the market expected a big move.

The report, August 5. The next day the stock fell 13%, from $26.03 to $22.68. That was the direction I wanted. The puts fell from $0.65 to $0.525, a 19% loss. Their IV dropped from 118% to 83% overnight.

FSLY Sep $17.50 putAug 5, before the reportAug 6, after the report
Stock price$26.03$22.68 (−13%)
Implied volatility118%83%
Put price$0.65$0.525 (−19%)
Delta−0.10−0.14

Why the put lost. A rough split of the $0.125 loss:

  • The stock move added about $0.45. The stock fell $3.35, and the put gained 10 to 14 cents for each dollar of the drop.
  • The IV drop took about $0.55 to $0.60. A vega of about $0.017 times a 35 point fall in IV.
  • One day of time decay took a few cents more.

The strike was the problem. At $17.50 the put was still 23% below the stock after the drop. Most of its price was volatility, and that is exactly the part that earnings remove.

The result. A week later the stock was back above $28 and the puts were worth $0.10. They expired worthless on September 18 with the stock at $23.86. Loss: $6,704. Net of the short puts, the position lost $5,593.

The same view, bought after the report

The thesis had not changed, so on August 17 and 18, after the crush, I bought 10 December $22.50 puts at an average of $2.52. IV was 84%, already reset. The strike was close to the stock price, so the puts would gain from a move rather than from volatility. The stock fell from $29 to about $21, and I sold the puts on September 3 at $4.60. Profit: $2,075, about 82%.

TradeBoughtIV at entryStrike vs stockResult
30 Sep $17.50 putsJuly 10, held through earningsabout 100%, rising to 118%far below−$6,704
10 Dec $22.50 putsAugust 17 to 18, after earnings84%near the stock+$2,075

How I avoid IV crush now

  1. Buy after the report when I can. If the thesis is about the next few months, not the report itself, I wait for IV to reset. The December puts show the difference.
  2. Keep a short leg through the event. A short option of the same type loses IV too, and that gain offsets part of the crush. I closed my short puts the day before the report and removed that offset. I explain how I pair long and short legs in Vertical vs Calendar Spreads and How to Match an Options Structure to a Catalyst.
  3. Avoid far out-of-the-money strikes into earnings. They are mostly volatility. A strike near the stock price gains more from the move itself.
  4. Check the expected move. The price of the at-the-money straddle for the nearest expiration is roughly the move the market expects. If my view is not bigger than that, I do not buy options into the report. My trade structuring agent runs this check before every trade: AI Options Trading.
  5. Close what has not worked within a month. I held these puts for over two months. My October recap shows why I now close positions that have not worked within a month.

FAQ

How much does IV drop after earnings?

It depends on the stock and on how much was priced in. On FSLY in August, IV on the September puts fell 35 points, from 118% to 83%, in one session. Options that expire soonest after the report usually fall the most.

Does IV crush affect both calls and puts?

Yes. IV crush is a fall in volatility, not in price, so it lowers the value of every long option on the stock, calls and puts alike.

Can you profit from IV crush?

Yes, by selling options before the event. The seller collects the high premium and gains as IV falls. The risk is a move bigger than priced in, which can cost far more than the premium collected. That is why I size short options below the long ones.

When does IV crush happen?

Right after the event that caused the uncertainty: usually at the first open after an earnings report, and also after FDA decisions, court rulings or economic data releases.


Every trade I make is part of a live record, losses included. See the Track Record, or book a free walkthrough of the Method to see how I pick the structure for a trade.

This post is educational and is not investment advice. Options involve substantial risk and are not suitable for every investor.